3.1.11

Disruption of Attachment - Privation

Test yourself

Privation - Bulldog Banks Study

Privation happens when children are not given the opportunity to form attachment bonds. This can have a very negative effect on children's development. Case studies provide insight into privation.

Illustrative background for PrivationIllustrative background for Privation ?? "content

Privation

  • Privation is a situation where no attachment bond ever has the opportunity to form.
  • While studies of maternal deprivation can look at large samples and correlate these samples with later outcomes, studies of privation must rely on case studies (a detailed investigation of a single participant).
  • Privation is more likely to result in lasting damage than deprivation. But research results don’t always agree with each other. Some individuals recover while others don't improve.
Illustrative background for Bulldog Banks studyIllustrative background for Bulldog Banks study ?? "content

Bulldog Banks study

  • Freud and Dann (1951) reported on a group of children who became known as the Bulldog Bank children. They were six refugees aged between three and four discovered by Russian troops at a concentration camp in what is now the Czech Republic.
  • It was believed that the children were orphaned at only a few months old and so had no time to form any attachments.
  • While at the reception centre for refugee children, it was decided that all six of the children should stay together at the Bulldog Banks Centre in West Sussex.
Illustrative background for Children's behaviourIllustrative background for Children's behaviour ?? "content

Children's behaviour

  • The children could be highly aggressive and would spit and hit adults who tried to restrict their movements or behaviour. They had no idea what toys were for and would destroy them.
  • Their language skills were limited, which increased their levels of aggression and hostility. They would only engage with staff if they needed something.
  • But the children were devoted to each other and were very fair. For example, they insisted that each member of the group received the same share of food at mealtimes.
Illustrative background for Outcome of studyIllustrative background for Outcome of study ?? "content

Outcome of study

  • With careful nurturing and support from staff, all children made rapid improvement. They displayed consideration and helpfulness to the staff, as well as identifying with adults in ways previously not seen.
  • Eventually, all the children were adopted and continued to make good progress.
  • The Bulldog Banks six weakens Bowlby’s maternal deprivation hypothesis because the children recovered from their early traumatic experiences.

Privation - Genie Study

Privation happens when children are not given the opportunity to form attachment bonds. This can have a very negative effect on children's development. Case studies provide insight into privation.

Illustrative background for Genie - before 18Illustrative background for Genie - before 18 ?? "content

Genie - before 18

  • Curtiss (1977) and Rymer (1993) reported on a girl known as Genie who was denied human contact, beaten and strapped to a potty seat until she was discovered at the age of 13.
  • Genie could not stand or speak and spent most of her time spitting.
  • She began to develop some language skills and her IQ improved from 38 to 74 between 1971 and 1977.
Illustrative background for Genie - after 18Illustrative background for Genie - after 18 ?? "content

Genie - after 18

  • At 18, she was returned to her mother but only stayed for a few months before being accommodated in a series of foster homes, where she was further abused. This lead to further deprivation.
Illustrative background for Evaluation of Genie and other studiesIllustrative background for Evaluation of Genie and other studies ?? "content

Evaluation of Genie and other studies

  • While the Bulldog Banks children had each other, Genie was raised in isolation. So it might have been the children's attachment to each other that helped with their recovery.
  • Bowlby overstated the negative effects of maternal deprivation because those children who received care and sensitivity went on to make good recoveries.
  • Case studies are dependent upon retrospective memories that are often incorrect. For example, Genie’s mother often gave conflicting reports of what happened to her daughter.

Quinton et al (1984) - Study on Women in Institutional Care

Research aim: To investigate the long-term effects of privation.

Illustrative background for Participants Illustrative background for Participants  ?? "content

Participants

  • A prospective follow-up study of two groups of women, first seen in the 60s.
  • Participants:
    • 94 participants had been reared in institutions because of a breakdown in parenting.
    • A control group of 51 women from the general population.
Illustrative background for ProcedureIllustrative background for Procedure ?? "content

Procedure

  • Records from the institution were examined.
  • Both groups were interviewed when they were aged 21–27 years, and home observations were undertaken for those with young children.
  • Interviews focused on their recall of their childhood; their later family, peer, and work experiences; and their current circumstances, functioning, and adjustment.
Illustrative background for Results & conclusion Illustrative background for Results & conclusion  ?? "content

Results & conclusion

  • Results
    • The institution group showed poorer psychosocial functioning and were more likely to report parenting difficulties. However, a supportive spouse and good living conditions did mitigate these findings in some of the institution women.
  • Conclusion
    • Privation can have long-term effects and these are often linked to parenting difficulties (lack of positive role models).
Illustrative background for Evaluation Illustrative background for Evaluation  ?? "content

Evaluation

  • Strengths
    • Detailed and in-depth records
    • Standardised questionnaire and observations increase reliability.
  • Limitations
    • Follow up studies rely on memory, which may not be accurate.
    • It could be that social and economic factors play a larger role than early privation.
    • Questionnaires may lack validity - leading to demand characteristics and social desirability.

Jump to other topics

1Social Influence

2Memory

3Attachment

4Psychopathology

5Approaches in Psychology

6Biopsychology

7Research Methods

8Issues & Debates in Psychology (A2 only)

9Option 1: Relationships (A2 only)

10Option 1: Gender (A2 only)

11Option 1: Cognition & Development (A2 only)

12Option 2: Schizophrenia (A2 only)

13Option 2: Eating Behaviour (A2 only)

14Option 2: Stress (A2 only)

15Option 3: Aggression (A2 only)

16Option 3: Forensic Psychology (A2 only)

17Option 3: Addiction (A2 only)

Go student ad image

Unlock your full potential with GoStudent tutoring

  • Affordable 1:1 tutoring from the comfort of your home

  • Tutors are matched to your specific learning needs

  • 30+ school subjects covered

Book a free trial lesson