16.1.10

Moral Reasoning

Test yourself

Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Reasoning and Criminal Behaviour

Kohlberg stated that moral reasoning occurs through three levels. Allen et al. (2001) concluded that criminals tended to have lower levels of moral reasoning.

Illustrative background for Moral reasoning Illustrative background for Moral reasoning  ?? "content

Moral reasoning

  • According to Kohlberg people develop their moral reasoning as they get older, similar to Piaget's model of cognitive development.
  • He believed that moral reasoning improved with age and people were better able to understand the position of other people and society in general.
  • He investigated moral reasoning by presenting boys with moral dilemmas.
Illustrative background for __Kohlberg__ methodIllustrative background for __Kohlberg__ method ?? "content

Kohlberg method

  • Kohlberg conducted his study on 72 boys aged 10, 13, and 16.
  • The participants were presented with 10 moral dilemmas and asked to state whether or not Heinz’s choice in each was justified.
    • One of the more famous examples is the ‘Heinz dilemma’, in which Heinz steals life-saving medicine to save his dying wife.
Illustrative background for MethodIllustrative background for Method ?? "content

Method

  • The boys were also asked to give the reasons behind their answers, from which Kohlberg developed his 3 levels of moral reasoning.
  • This progression occurs through a series of 3 levels broken into 6 stages.

3 Levels of Moral Reasoning (Kohlberg)

Kohlberg developed 3 levels of moral reasoning, which he then broke into 6 stages.

Illustrative background for Level 1: Preconventional reasoningIllustrative background for Level 1: Preconventional reasoning ?? "content

Level 1: Preconventional reasoning

  • Level 1: Preconventional reasoning
    • 1) Most common in children - if a person is punished, then the action must be morally wrong.
      • In terms of the dilemma: Heinz should be punished for stealing.
Illustrative background for Level 1: Preconventional reasoningIllustrative background for Level 1: Preconventional reasoning ?? "content

Level 1: Preconventional reasoning

  • Level 1: Preconventional reasoning
    • 2) The correct action is the one that best serves one’s own self-interest.
      • Heinz should steal the medicine to save his dying wife as that will make him happy.
Illustrative background for Level 2: Conventional reasoningIllustrative background for Level 2: Conventional reasoning ?? "content

Level 2: Conventional reasoning

  • Level 2: Conventional reasoning
    • 3) The correct behaviour/action is one where other people will think positively about you.
      • Heinz steals the medicine to make his wife happy, that is what she expects of him.
Illustrative background for Level 2: Conventional reasoningIllustrative background for Level 2: Conventional reasoning ?? "content

Level 2: Conventional reasoning

  • Level 2: Conventional reasoning
    • 4) It is important that people obey society’s laws and norms, this is crucial for a functioning society.
      • Heinz should not steal the medicine as it is breaking the law.
  • (Most people fall somewhere within level 2.)
Illustrative background for Level 3: Postconventional reasoning Illustrative background for Level 3: Postconventional reasoning  ?? "content

Level 3: Postconventional reasoning

  • Level 3: Postconventional reasoning
    • 5) The correct course of action is the one where the most people benefit and it is for the greater good of society.
      • Heinz should steal the medicine as everyone has the right to life.
Illustrative background for Level 3: Postconventional reasoning Illustrative background for Level 3: Postconventional reasoning  ?? "content

Level 3: Postconventional reasoning

  • Level 3: Postconventional reasoning
    • 6) The actions and behaviours of an individual are guided by universal and abstract principles of morality.
    • These do not take into account individual situations.
      • Heinz should steal the medicine because life is always more important than the material value of something like medicine.

Evaluation of Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Development

There are two main criticisms regarding Kohlberg’s theory of moral development. Allen et al. (2001) concluded that criminals tended to have lower levels of moral reasoning.

Illustrative background for Gender biasIllustrative background for Gender bias ?? "content

Gender bias

  • The study was conducted with an all-male sample.
  • However Kohlberg generalised his findings to the entire population.
  • This demonstrates beta bias, whereby the differences between men and women are minimised.
Illustrative background for AndrocentricIllustrative background for Androcentric ?? "content

Androcentric

  • His research focussed on males and male moral reasoning.
  • This means it is androcentric.
  • Gilligan (1982) stated that male-oriented ideas were the focus and that female moral approaches should have also been taken into account.
Illustrative background for __Allen et al. (2001)__Illustrative background for __Allen et al. (2001)__ ?? "content

Allen et al. (2001)

  • Criminals tend to have lower levels of moral reasoning (Allen et al, 2001).
  • Criminals also tend not to progress through the stages in the same way of the majority of non-criminals.
  • Serious offenders (murderers and rapists) have different perspectives of moral reasoning than the norm.

Jump to other topics

1Social Influence

2Memory

3Attachment

4Psychopathology

5Approaches in Psychology

6Biopsychology

7Research Methods

8Issues & Debates in Psychology (A2 only)

9Option 1: Relationships (A2 only)

10Option 1: Gender (A2 only)

11Option 1: Cognition & Development (A2 only)

12Option 2: Schizophrenia (A2 only)

13Option 2: Eating Behaviour (A2 only)

14Option 2: Stress (A2 only)

15Option 3: Aggression (A2 only)

16Option 3: Forensic Psychology (A2 only)

17Option 3: Addiction (A2 only)

Go student ad image

Unlock your full potential with GoStudent tutoring

  • Affordable 1:1 tutoring from the comfort of your home

  • Tutors are matched to your specific learning needs

  • 30+ school subjects covered

Book a free trial lesson