10.1.3

Marxism

Test yourself

Marxism

Marxists discuss the concept of criminogenic capitalism, this means that crime is inevitable in a capitalist society and all social classes are committing crime.

Illustrative background for __Box__Illustrative background for __Box__ ?? "content

Box

  • Marxists such as Box claim that the law is written by the bourgeoisie and therefore only reflects their interests.
  • This is referred to as ideological law making.
Illustrative background for __Chambliss__Illustrative background for __Chambliss__ ?? "content

Chambliss

  • Chambliss claims that the criminal justice system disproportionately focuses on the actions of the proletariat in order to control their actions.
  • On the other hand, the bourgeoisie’s acts are ignored this is known as selective law enforcement.
Illustrative background for False class consciousnessIllustrative background for False class consciousness ?? "content

False class consciousness

  • Marxists argue the law can be useful in maintaining false class consciousness.
  • At times, the bourgeoisie will allow laws that seem to help the proletariat such as the minimum wage and health and safety regulations in the workplace.
Illustrative background for The caring face of capitalismIllustrative background for The caring face of capitalism ?? "content

The caring face of capitalism

  • However, Pearce claims these laws are rarely enforced and usually benefit the bourgeoisie as a healthy and happy workforce is more productive and obedient, this is referred to as the caring face of capitalism.

Moral Entrepreneurs

Becker argues that the role of moral entrepreneurs is significant in our reaction to particular acts.

Illustrative background for __Becker__Illustrative background for __Becker__ ?? "content

Becker

  • A ‘moral entrepreneur’ is someone who attempts to influence our reaction in order to change the law.
  • These are usually journalists, politicians or members of the criminal justice system.
  • Moral entrepreneurs begin to influence other people’s opinions, which then in turn affects the labelling process. 
Illustrative background for __Cicourel__Illustrative background for __Cicourel__ ?? "content

Cicourel

  • Cicourel claimed that police officers and judges use typifications or stereotypes to influence their judgement of an offender.
  • If the offender fits their expectations of a typical criminal, they are more likely to arrest them.
Illustrative background for Primary devianceIllustrative background for Primary deviance ?? "content

Primary deviance

  • Lemert studied the difference between what he calls  ‘primary’ and  ‘secondary’ deviance.
  • This is covered in the next module.

Labelling Theory

Lemert studied the difference between what he calls  ‘primary’ and  ‘secondary’ deviance.

Illustrative background for Primary devianceIllustrative background for Primary deviance ?? "content

Primary deviance

  • Although technically illegal the criminal label is not attached as people tend to see it as ‘primary deviance’.
  • As the criminal label is not attached, it does not affect the ‘self-concept’ of the individual and a result no labelling takes place.
Illustrative background for Secondary devianceIllustrative background for Secondary deviance ?? "content

Secondary deviance

  • An act that generates a strong response and results in a label being attached to the offender.
  • After being labelled, an offender may experience consequences such as punishment or humiliation.
  • This label becomes the person’s master status and therefore their controlling identity.
  • This leads to the self-fulfilling prophecy and as a result more crime.
Illustrative background for Deviance amplification spiralIllustrative background for Deviance amplification spiral ?? "content

Deviance amplification spiral

  • Secondary deviance causes a deviance amplification spiral.
  • If a moral entrepreneur changes the public perception on a particular act from ‘primary’ to secondary’ deviance, it could lead to further crime.
Illustrative background for The mediaIllustrative background for The media ?? "content

The media

  • The media become central to the deviancy amplification spiral.
  • They represent the deviant group in a negative way and as a result the self-fulfilling prophecy will take hold and more crime will occur.
Illustrative background for __Braithwaite__Illustrative background for __Braithwaite__ ?? "content

Braithwaite

  • Braithwaite suggests that labelling can be used to reintegrate offenders, rather than marginalise them.
  • He refers to this process as reintegrative shaming. 
Illustrative background for Reintegrative shamingIllustrative background for Reintegrative shaming ?? "content

Reintegrative shaming

  • He claims ‘reintegrative shaming’ is more effective and focuses more on the act, rather than the individual.
  • Braithwaite says this is more useful than disintegrative shaming that labels the criminal and outcasts them from society.

Jump to other topics

1Theory & Methods

2Education with Methods in Context

3Option 1: Culture & Identity

4Option 1: Families & Households

5Option 1: Health

6Option 1: Work, Poverty & Welfare

7Option 2: Beliefs in Society

8Option 2: Global Development

9Option 2: The Media

10Crime & Deviance

Go student ad image

Unlock your full potential with GoStudent tutoring

  • Affordable 1:1 tutoring from the comfort of your home

  • Tutors are matched to your specific learning needs

  • 30+ school subjects covered

Book a free trial lesson