13.2.2

Legislative

Test yourself

Legislative Process

The Constitution grants all legislative powers to Congress. Bills (pieces of legislation) must pass through both chambers and needs the signature of the president to become law.

Illustrative background for Initiation of billsIllustrative background for Initiation of bills ?? "content

Initiation of bills

  • Bills can be initiated by any member of Congress but are usually initiated by party leaders in Congress or committee chairs, often on behalf of the president.
  • Bills need to be signed by a sponsor - and there can be many co-sponsors.
Illustrative background for Committee stageIllustrative background for Committee stage ?? "content

Committee stage

  • After they have been initiated (the first reading) bills are passed on to the relevant committees (in both House and Senate) where they are debated and amended (or ‘marked up’).
  • Committees can choose whether or not to ‘hear’ a bill, and bills that are not heard will die in committee.
Illustrative background for Legislation brought to the floorIllustrative background for Legislation brought to the floor ?? "content

Legislation brought to the floor

  • If a bill passes committee stage it goes to the House Rules Committee or the Senate leadership to be scheduled for voting and debate. If a bill is not scheduled in both houses it will die.
  • Once a bill is scheduled it has a second reading in both houses where it is further debated and amended, this is followed by a vote which the bill must pass in both houses for it to continue.
  • The third reading is the final chance to debate the bill before a final vote.
Illustrative background for Conference stageIllustrative background for Conference stage ?? "content

Conference stage

  • As legislation passes through both chambers at the same time, there are often two very different versions of the bill which need to be reconciled.
  • Sometimes a conference committee is set up to reach a compromise on a final bill, other times this is done by congressional leadership.
  • The reconciled bill must then pass a vote in both chambers, if it fails in one chamber then it will die.
Illustrative background for The presidentIllustrative background for The president ?? "content

The president

  • Once a bill has passed all of these stages it must be signed into law by the president. A president has the power to veto (not sign) a bill and send it back to Congress.
  • A 2/3 vote in both chambers of Congress can override a veto, as happened to Obama in 2016 with the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act.

Strengths and Weaknesses of the Legislative Process

The legislative process has strengths of having extra checks and balances and ensuring high quality legislation. However, weaknesses include that the process can be long and ineffective.

Illustrative background for EffectiveIllustrative background for Effective ?? "content

Effective

  • The fact that bills must pass through both houses gives extra checks and balances and prevents potential tyranny.
  • Rules in the Senate such as the filibuster protect state's rights.
  • If neither party in the Senate has 60 seats, the minority party can filibuster, meaning that the minority views must be taken into account and compromise reached in order for the majority party to get 60 votes and break the filibuster.
  • The long process used to pass legislation means that bills are not rushed and should be of a higher quality, with more debate and consideration.
Illustrative background for Not effective: gridlockIllustrative background for Not effective: gridlock ?? "content

Not effective: gridlock

  • The increased use of the filibuster in the Senate now means that on most occasions, legislation needs 60 votes to pass in the Senate.
  • Increased partisanship in recent years has led to gridlock under divided governments and has even led to government shutdowns in 2013 and 2018.
  • Increased partisanship and subsequent gridlock have also led to a low output of legislation with the 112th Congress (2010-2012) passing only 283 pieces of legislation, the lowest in history, and subsequent Congresses doing little better.
Illustrative background for Not effectiveIllustrative background for Not effective ?? "content

Not effective

  • Many argue that committees, in particular committee chairs, have too much power over the legislation that passes through.
  • Pork barrelling is when members of Congress allocate federal money for projects in and benefits to their own constituencies. This funding usually only serves local interests.
    • Pork barrelling is often attached to other pieces of legislation as part of a deal to get a bill passed.
  • During several stages of the legislative process, particularly the conference stage, key parts of the bill may be removed as part of compromises made get the bill passed.

Differences in the Legislative Processes

The legislative processes in the House and Senate have a few differences.

Illustrative background for Differences in each chamber: HouseIllustrative background for Differences in each chamber: House ?? "content

Differences in each chamber: House

  • Representatives in the House have restricted time to speak on the floor.
    • This may be limited during “controlled” time, where members are chosen to speak for or against a bill, and given a specified time and order in which to speak.
    • Otherwise, this time is not controlled, and speakers are granted permission from the chair of the debate, and usually have five minutes to speak.
  • During a debate, representatives must limit their speeches to the subject being debated.
Illustrative background for Differences in each chamber: HouseIllustrative background for Differences in each chamber: House ?? "content

Differences in each chamber: House

  • Only the House can initiate bills that involve raising revenue, and the Senate can propose amendments.
    • This makes sure that the ‘power of the purse’ is held by the legislative body that is most representative of the public.
Illustrative background for Differences in each chamber: SenateIllustrative background for Differences in each chamber: Senate ?? "content

Differences in each chamber: Senate

  • Senators can speak for unlimited time on any topic they wish, which can be used to filibuster a bill.
    • A filibuster ends by three-fifths of the Senators voting to invoke cloture.
  • Senators can’t make more than two speeches on the same day on a bill.
  • The Senate cannot introduce a money bill.

Jump to other topics

1Democracy & Participation

2Political Parties

3Electoral Systems

4Voting Behaviour & the Media

5Conservatism

6Liberalism

7Socialism

8The UK Constitution

9The UK Parliament

10The Prime Minister & the Executive

11Relationships Between Government Branches

12US Constitution & Federalism

13US Congress

14US Presidency

15US Supreme Court & Civil Rights

16US Democracy & Participation

17Comparing Democracies

18Feminism

19Nationalism

Go student ad image

Unlock your full potential with GoStudent tutoring

  • Affordable 1:1 tutoring from the comfort of your home

  • Tutors are matched to your specific learning needs

  • 30+ school subjects covered

Book a free trial lesson