5.2.2

Peer Review

Test yourself on Peer Review

Test your knowledge with free interactive questions on Seneca — used by over 10 million students.

Peer-Reviewing

Peer-reviewing is an important step of the process of having an article published, where other scientists provide feedback on the study. It helps to provide a level of quality control to research.

Peer-reviewed journal

Peer-reviewed journal

A peer-reviewed journal article is read by several other scientists (generally anonymously) with expertise in the subject matter.
These peer reviewers provide feedback - to both the author and the journal editor -regarding the quality of the draft.
Ultimately, the journal editor will compile all of the peer reviewer feedback and determine whether the article will be published in its current state (a rare occurrence), published with revisions, or not accepted for publication.

Peer-review feedback

Peer-review feedback

Peer reviewers look for a strong rationale for the research being described, a clear description of how the research was conducted, and evidence that the research was conducted in an ethical manner.
They look for flaws in the study's design, methods, and statistical analyses.
They check that the conclusions drawn by the authors seem reasonable given the observations made during the research.
Peer reviewers also comment on how valuable the research is in advancing the discipline’s knowledge.

Use of peer-reviewing

Use of peer-reviewing

Peer-reviewing helps prevent unnecessary duplication of research findings in the scientific literature and, to some extent, makes sure that each research article provides new information.
Peer review provides some degree of quality control for psychological research.
Poorly conceived or executed studies can be weeded out, and even well-designed research can be improved by the revisions suggested.

Peer review for replication

Peer review for replication

Peer review also makes sure that the research is described clearly enough to allow other scientists to replicate it, meaning they can repeat the experiment using different samples to determine reliability.

Replication

Replication

Each replication of a study serves to provide more evidence to support the original research findings. Often, replications involve additional measures that expand on the original finding.
Successful replications of published research make scientists more apt to adopt those findings, while repeated failures tend to cast doubt on the legitimacy of the original article.

Replication example

Replication example

For example, it would be a major advancement in the medical field if a published study indicated that taking a new drug helped individuals achieve a healthy weight without changing their diet.
But if other scientists could not replicate the results, the original study’s claims would be questioned.

1

Principles of Science I

1.1

Structure & Bonding

1.1.1Atomic Model 1.1.2Electron Shells, Sub-Shells & Orbitals 1.1.3Ionic Bonding 1.1.4Representing Ionic Bonds 1.1.5Covalent Bonding 1.1.6Representing Covalent Bonds 1.1.7Metallic Bonding 1.1.8Intermolecular Forces 1.1.9Intermolecular Forces 2 1.1.10End of Topic Test - Bonding 1.1.11Relative Masses 1.1.12The Mole 1.1.13Molar Calculations 1.1.14Molar Calculations 2 1.1.15Empirical & Molecular Formulae 1.1.16Balanced Equations 1.1.17Percentage Yield 1.1.18End of Topic Test - Amount of Substance

1.2

Properties of Substances

1.2.1The Periodic Table 1.2.2Ionisation Energy 1.2.3Factors Affecting Ionisation Energies 1.2.4Trends of Ionisation 1.2.5Trends in the Periodic Table 1.2.6Polarity 1.2.7Metals & Non-Metals 1.2.8Alkali Metals 1.2.9Alkaline Earth Metals 1.2.10Reactivity of Alkaline Earth Metals 1.2.11Redox 1.2.12Transition Metals 1.2.13Redox Reactions of Transition Metals

1.3

Cell Structure & Function

1.3.1Introduction to Cells 1.3.2Prokaryotes 1.3.3Organelles of Eukaryotic Cells 1.3.4Organelles of Eukaryotic Cells 2 1.3.5Organelles in Plant Cells 1.3.6Microscopy 1.3.7End of Topic Test - Cell Structure

1.4

Cell Specialisation

1.4.1Cell Specialisation 1.4.2Blood Cells 1.4.3Plant Cells 1.4.4Gametes

1.5

Tissue Structure & Function

1.5.1Human Gas Exchange 1.5.2Blood Vessels 1.5.3Atherosclerosis 1.5.4Skeletal Muscle 1.5.5Slow & Fast Twitch Fibres 1.5.6Neurones 1.5.7Speed of Transmission 1.5.8Action Potentials 1.5.9End of Topic Test - Neurones & Action Potentials 1.5.10Synapses 1.5.11Types of Synapse 1.5.12Medical Application 1.5.13End of Topic Test - Synapses 1.5.14Chemical Brain Imbalances 1.5.15Effect of Drugs on the Brain

1.6

Working with Waves

1.6.1Progressive Waves 1.6.2Wave Speed & Phase Difference 1.6.3Longitudinal & Transverse Waves 1.6.4Stationary Waves 1.6.5Stationary Waves 2 1.6.6Applications of Stationary Waves 1.6.7Interference 1.6.8Diffraction 1.6.9Diffraction Gratings 1.6.10Application of Diffraction Gratings

1.7

Waves in Communication

1.7.1Refraction at a Plane Surface 1.7.2Internal Reflection & Fibre Optics 1.7.3Applications of Total Internal Reflection 1.7.4Properties 1.7.5Gamma, X-Ray & UV Light 1.7.6Visible Light 1.7.7Infrared, Microwave & Radio Waves 1.7.8Intensity 1.7.9Digital & Analogue Signals 1.7.10Communication Channels

2

Practical Scientific Procedures and Techniques

2.1

Titration

2.1.1pH Curves & Titrations 2.1.2pH Curves & Titrations 2 2.1.3Buffer Solutions

2.2

Colorimetry

2.2.1Measuring Rates 2.2.2Beer-Lambert Law

2.3

Chromatography

2.3.1Overview of Chromatography 2.3.2Thin-Layer Chromatography 2.3.3Column Chromatography 2.3.4Gas Chromatography

3

Science Investigation Skills

3.1

Scientific Processes

3.1.1Aims, Hypotheses & Sampling 3.1.2Pilot Studies & Design 3.1.3Ethics 3.1.4Variables & Control 3.1.5Demand Characteristics & Investigator Effects 3.1.6Features of Science 3.1.7Scientific Report 3.1.8Scientific Report 2

3.2

Data Handling & Analysis

3.2.1Types of Data 3.2.2Descriptive Statistics 3.2.3Presentation & Display of Data

3.3

Enzymes in Action

3.3.1Overview of Protein Structure 3.3.2Enzymes 3.3.3Factors Affecting Enzyme Activity 3.3.4Enzyme-Controlled Reactions

3.4

Diffusion

3.5

Plants & Their Environment

3.5.1Factors Affecting Plant Growth 3.5.2Measuring Number & Distribution of Species

3.6

Energy Content in Fuels

3.6.1Fractions 3.6.2Burning Hydrocarbons 3.6.3Combustion 3.6.4Energy 3.6.5Energy at Home 3.6.6Calorimetry

3.7

Electrical Circuits

3.7.1Circuit Diagrams & Components 3.7.2Diodes, LDRs & Thermistors 3.7.3Resistance 3.7.4Electrical Work 3.7.5Ohm's Law 3.7.6Domestic Uses of Electricity 3.7.7Fuses

4

Principles of Science II

4.1

Extracting Elements

4.1.1Atom Economy

4.2

Relating Properties to use of Substances

4.2.1Group 2 Chemistry 4.2.2End of Topic Test - Group 2 4.2.3Electrolysis 4.2.4Electrolysis Examples 4.2.5Extracting Metals 4.2.6Transition Metals 4.2.7Variable Oxidation States 4.2.8Heterogeneous Catalysts 4.2.9Homogeneous Catalysts

4.3

Organic Chemistry

4.3.1Naming Compounds 4.3.2Functional Groups 4.3.3Isomerism 4.3.4Hydrocarbons 4.3.5Structure of Alkanes 4.3.6Boiling Points of Alkanes 4.3.7Alkenes 4.3.8Curly Arrows & Mechanisms 4.3.9Cracking 4.3.10Combustion 4.3.11Free Radical Substitution of Alkanes 4.3.12Electrophilic Addition of Alkenes

4.4

Energy Changes in Industry

4.4.1The Kelvin Scale 4.4.2Enthalpy Changes 4.4.3Calorimetry 4.4.4Bond Enthalpies 4.4.5Hess' Law

4.5

The Circulatory System

4.5.1The Circulatory System 4.5.2Blood Vessels 4.5.3Blood Transfusion & the ABO Rhesus System 4.5.4The Heart 4.5.5The Cardiac Cycle 4.5.6Cardiac Output 4.5.7Coordination of Heart Action 4.5.8Heart Dissection 4.5.9Controlling Heart Rate 4.5.10Electrocardiograms 4.5.11Cardiovascular Disease 4.5.12Investigating Heart Rates

4.6

Ventilation & Gas Exchange

4.6.1Human Gas Exchange 4.6.2Ventilation 4.6.3Measuring Gas Exchange 4.6.4Controlling Ventilation Rate 4.6.5Lung Disease 4.6.6Lung Disease Data

4.7

Urinary System

4.7.1Kidneys & Control of Water Balance 4.7.2Kidneys & Osmoregulation 4.7.3Kidneys & Blood Pressure 4.7.4Urine 4.7.5Kidney Failure & Urinalysis 4.7.6Dialysis 4.7.7Transplants

4.8

Cell Transport

4.8.1Cell Membrane Structure 4.8.2Diffusion 4.8.3Osmosis 4.8.4Active Transport

4.9

Thermal Physics

4.9.1Power & Efficiency 4.9.2Work & Energy 4.9.3Conservation of Energy 4.9.4Pressure 4.9.5First Law of Thermodynamics 4.9.6Second Law of Thermodynamics 4.9.7Heat Engines, Heat Pumps & Refrigerators 4.9.8Non-Flow Processes 4.9.9p-V Diagrams 4.9.10Ideal Gases 4.9.11Ideal Gases 2 4.9.12Thermal Energy Transfer 4.9.13Thermal Energy Transfer Experiments

4.10

Materials

4.10.1Density 4.10.2Stress & Strain 4.10.3Properties of Materials 4.10.4Elasticity 4.10.5Plasticity 4.10.6Energy in Materials 4.10.7Young Modulus

4.11

Fluids

4.11.1Fluid Flow 4.11.2Viscosity 4.11.3Density 4.11.4Continuity Equation 4.11.5Bernoulli's Equation 4.11.6Non-Newtonian Fluids

5

Contemporary Issues in Science

5.1

Contemporary Issues in Science

5.1.1Sustainability 5.1.2Genetic Engineering 5.1.3Uses of Genetic Modification 5.1.4Stem Cell Therapy 5.1.5Cloning 5.1.6Cloning 2 5.1.7Nanotechnology 5.1.8Ecosystems

5.2

Analysing Scientific Information

5.2.1Validity 5.2.2Peer Review

Jump to other topics

1

Principles of Science I

1.1

Structure & Bonding

1.1.1Atomic Model 1.1.2Electron Shells, Sub-Shells & Orbitals 1.1.3Ionic Bonding 1.1.4Representing Ionic Bonds 1.1.5Covalent Bonding 1.1.6Representing Covalent Bonds 1.1.7Metallic Bonding 1.1.8Intermolecular Forces 1.1.9Intermolecular Forces 2 1.1.10End of Topic Test - Bonding 1.1.11Relative Masses 1.1.12The Mole 1.1.13Molar Calculations 1.1.14Molar Calculations 2 1.1.15Empirical & Molecular Formulae 1.1.16Balanced Equations 1.1.17Percentage Yield 1.1.18End of Topic Test - Amount of Substance

1.2

Properties of Substances

1.2.1The Periodic Table 1.2.2Ionisation Energy 1.2.3Factors Affecting Ionisation Energies 1.2.4Trends of Ionisation 1.2.5Trends in the Periodic Table 1.2.6Polarity 1.2.7Metals & Non-Metals 1.2.8Alkali Metals 1.2.9Alkaline Earth Metals 1.2.10Reactivity of Alkaline Earth Metals 1.2.11Redox 1.2.12Transition Metals 1.2.13Redox Reactions of Transition Metals

1.3

Cell Structure & Function

1.3.1Introduction to Cells 1.3.2Prokaryotes 1.3.3Organelles of Eukaryotic Cells 1.3.4Organelles of Eukaryotic Cells 2 1.3.5Organelles in Plant Cells 1.3.6Microscopy 1.3.7End of Topic Test - Cell Structure

1.4

Cell Specialisation

1.4.1Cell Specialisation 1.4.2Blood Cells 1.4.3Plant Cells 1.4.4Gametes

1.5

Tissue Structure & Function

1.5.1Human Gas Exchange 1.5.2Blood Vessels 1.5.3Atherosclerosis 1.5.4Skeletal Muscle 1.5.5Slow & Fast Twitch Fibres 1.5.6Neurones 1.5.7Speed of Transmission 1.5.8Action Potentials 1.5.9End of Topic Test - Neurones & Action Potentials 1.5.10Synapses 1.5.11Types of Synapse 1.5.12Medical Application 1.5.13End of Topic Test - Synapses 1.5.14Chemical Brain Imbalances 1.5.15Effect of Drugs on the Brain

1.6

Working with Waves

1.6.1Progressive Waves 1.6.2Wave Speed & Phase Difference 1.6.3Longitudinal & Transverse Waves 1.6.4Stationary Waves 1.6.5Stationary Waves 2 1.6.6Applications of Stationary Waves 1.6.7Interference 1.6.8Diffraction 1.6.9Diffraction Gratings 1.6.10Application of Diffraction Gratings

1.7

Waves in Communication

1.7.1Refraction at a Plane Surface 1.7.2Internal Reflection & Fibre Optics 1.7.3Applications of Total Internal Reflection 1.7.4Properties 1.7.5Gamma, X-Ray & UV Light 1.7.6Visible Light 1.7.7Infrared, Microwave & Radio Waves 1.7.8Intensity 1.7.9Digital & Analogue Signals 1.7.10Communication Channels

2

Practical Scientific Procedures and Techniques

2.1

Titration

2.1.1pH Curves & Titrations 2.1.2pH Curves & Titrations 2 2.1.3Buffer Solutions

2.2

Colorimetry

2.2.1Measuring Rates 2.2.2Beer-Lambert Law

2.3

Chromatography

2.3.1Overview of Chromatography 2.3.2Thin-Layer Chromatography 2.3.3Column Chromatography 2.3.4Gas Chromatography

3

Science Investigation Skills

3.1

Scientific Processes

3.1.1Aims, Hypotheses & Sampling 3.1.2Pilot Studies & Design 3.1.3Ethics 3.1.4Variables & Control 3.1.5Demand Characteristics & Investigator Effects 3.1.6Features of Science 3.1.7Scientific Report 3.1.8Scientific Report 2

3.2

Data Handling & Analysis

3.2.1Types of Data 3.2.2Descriptive Statistics 3.2.3Presentation & Display of Data

3.3

Enzymes in Action

3.3.1Overview of Protein Structure 3.3.2Enzymes 3.3.3Factors Affecting Enzyme Activity 3.3.4Enzyme-Controlled Reactions

3.4

Diffusion

3.5

Plants & Their Environment

3.5.1Factors Affecting Plant Growth 3.5.2Measuring Number & Distribution of Species

3.6

Energy Content in Fuels

3.6.1Fractions 3.6.2Burning Hydrocarbons 3.6.3Combustion 3.6.4Energy 3.6.5Energy at Home 3.6.6Calorimetry

3.7

Electrical Circuits

3.7.1Circuit Diagrams & Components 3.7.2Diodes, LDRs & Thermistors 3.7.3Resistance 3.7.4Electrical Work 3.7.5Ohm's Law 3.7.6Domestic Uses of Electricity 3.7.7Fuses

4

Principles of Science II

4.1

Extracting Elements

4.1.1Atom Economy

4.2

Relating Properties to use of Substances

4.2.1Group 2 Chemistry 4.2.2End of Topic Test - Group 2 4.2.3Electrolysis 4.2.4Electrolysis Examples 4.2.5Extracting Metals 4.2.6Transition Metals 4.2.7Variable Oxidation States 4.2.8Heterogeneous Catalysts 4.2.9Homogeneous Catalysts

4.3

Organic Chemistry

4.3.1Naming Compounds 4.3.2Functional Groups 4.3.3Isomerism 4.3.4Hydrocarbons 4.3.5Structure of Alkanes 4.3.6Boiling Points of Alkanes 4.3.7Alkenes 4.3.8Curly Arrows & Mechanisms 4.3.9Cracking 4.3.10Combustion 4.3.11Free Radical Substitution of Alkanes 4.3.12Electrophilic Addition of Alkenes

4.4

Energy Changes in Industry

4.4.1The Kelvin Scale 4.4.2Enthalpy Changes 4.4.3Calorimetry 4.4.4Bond Enthalpies 4.4.5Hess' Law

4.5

The Circulatory System

4.5.1The Circulatory System 4.5.2Blood Vessels 4.5.3Blood Transfusion & the ABO Rhesus System 4.5.4The Heart 4.5.5The Cardiac Cycle 4.5.6Cardiac Output 4.5.7Coordination of Heart Action 4.5.8Heart Dissection 4.5.9Controlling Heart Rate 4.5.10Electrocardiograms 4.5.11Cardiovascular Disease 4.5.12Investigating Heart Rates

4.6

Ventilation & Gas Exchange

4.6.1Human Gas Exchange 4.6.2Ventilation 4.6.3Measuring Gas Exchange 4.6.4Controlling Ventilation Rate 4.6.5Lung Disease 4.6.6Lung Disease Data

4.7

Urinary System

4.7.1Kidneys & Control of Water Balance 4.7.2Kidneys & Osmoregulation 4.7.3Kidneys & Blood Pressure 4.7.4Urine 4.7.5Kidney Failure & Urinalysis 4.7.6Dialysis 4.7.7Transplants

4.8

Cell Transport

4.8.1Cell Membrane Structure 4.8.2Diffusion 4.8.3Osmosis 4.8.4Active Transport

4.9

Thermal Physics

4.9.1Power & Efficiency 4.9.2Work & Energy 4.9.3Conservation of Energy 4.9.4Pressure 4.9.5First Law of Thermodynamics 4.9.6Second Law of Thermodynamics 4.9.7Heat Engines, Heat Pumps & Refrigerators 4.9.8Non-Flow Processes 4.9.9p-V Diagrams 4.9.10Ideal Gases 4.9.11Ideal Gases 2 4.9.12Thermal Energy Transfer 4.9.13Thermal Energy Transfer Experiments

4.10

Materials

4.10.1Density 4.10.2Stress & Strain 4.10.3Properties of Materials 4.10.4Elasticity 4.10.5Plasticity 4.10.6Energy in Materials 4.10.7Young Modulus

4.11

Fluids

4.11.1Fluid Flow 4.11.2Viscosity 4.11.3Density 4.11.4Continuity Equation 4.11.5Bernoulli's Equation 4.11.6Non-Newtonian Fluids

5

Contemporary Issues in Science

5.1

Contemporary Issues in Science

5.1.1Sustainability 5.1.2Genetic Engineering 5.1.3Uses of Genetic Modification 5.1.4Stem Cell Therapy 5.1.5Cloning 5.1.6Cloning 2 5.1.7Nanotechnology 5.1.8Ecosystems

5.2

Analysing Scientific Information

5.2.1Validity 5.2.2Peer Review

Practice questions on Peer Review

Can you answer these? Test yourself with free interactive practice on Seneca — used by over 10 million students.

1
Process of Peer Review FeedbackPut in order
2
Which of the following describes a study that can be performed by another scientist and achieve the same results?Multiple choice
3
What's least likely to happen to an article after the journal editor has received peer review feedback?Multiple choice

Answer all questions on Peer Review

Unlock your full potential with Seneca Premium

Unlimited access to 10,000+ open-ended exam questions
Mini-mock exams based on your study history
Unlock 800+ premium courses & e-books

Get started with Seneca Premium

Validity