Conformity to Social Roles

Psychology: AQA A Level, topic 1.1.5

Motivation to Conform

Researchers have categorised the motivation to conform into two types:

Normative social influence

Normative social influence

  • People conform to the group norm to fit in, to feel good, and to be accepted by the group.
  • In Asch's (1951) line judgement task, participants complied to fit in and avoid ridicule, an instance of normative social influence.
Informational social influence

Informational social influence

  • People conform because they believe the group is competent and has the correct information, particularly when the task or situation is ambiguous.
  • An example of informational social influence may be what to do in an emergency situation, e.g. if you are in a crowded cinema and see smoke coming out from under the fire exit. You are not certain that it is smoke as it may be a special effect for the movie, so you will tend to look at the behaviour of those around when deciding what to do.

Orlando (1973) - Mock Psychiatric Ward Experiment

Orlando (1973) looked at how people conformed to roles given to them in an experiment in a mock psychiatric ward.

Method

Method

  • The mock psychiatric ward was active for three days.
  • 51 staff members took part.
  • 29 volunteered as mock patients.
  • 22 worked their jobs as normal.
Results and conclusion

Results and conclusion

  • The mock patients quickly began acting like normal hospital patients. They conformed to their given roles.
  • Lots of patients showed signs of having withdrawal and depression.
  • Six mock patients attempted to escape the ward.
  • Some mock patients admitted to feelings of lost identity.
Analysis

Analysis

  • Orlando's (1973) study and similar studies give an insight into real patients' experiences in hospital.
  • Orlando's (1973) study influenced hospital staff to empathise more with patients.

Test yourself on Conformity to Social Roles

  • Which type of social influence does NOT underlie why people conform in Asch's line judgement task?

  • What are the two types of social influence that categorise the motivation to conform?

  • How did mock patients behave during Orlando's (1973) mock psychiatric ward experiment?

Practise this topic for free