Comparing Types of Democracy

Political Studies: Edexcel A Level, topic 1.1.5

Comparing Direct & Representative Democracies

There are some similarities between the two types of democracy, but mainly differences in the ways decisions are made.

Similarities

Similarities

  • Both representative and direct democracies are forms of democracy that allow voters to make important decisions.
Differences

Differences

  • Each and every voter makes decisions directly in direct democracies.
  • In representative democracies, a representative makes decisions on behalf of a large number of voters.
  • In representative democracies like the UK, constituency sizes vary, meaning votes may not be of equal value in practice.
  • Direct democracy uses public votes to make decisions directly.
  • In representative democracies, the votes for a representative are taken as a mandate for them to act on behalf of voters.
Mandates

Mandates

  • A mandate is the authority given by voters to a party to implement its policies following an election victory.
  • In a representative democracy, mandates are inferred from election results rather than direct policy votes.

Test yourself on Comparing Types of Democracy

  • What is a mandate?

  • Which of these is a similarity between representative and direct democracies?

Practise this topic for free