7.5.1

Detection in Atonement

Test yourself

Robbie and Cecilia as Detectives in Atonement

Atonement does not have an obvious detective figure. The police inspectors who arrive at the Tallis household are there for only two chapters. The focus of the novel then swiftly turns to the British army’s retreat to Dunkirk.

Illustrative background for Robbie's theory about BrionyIllustrative background for Robbie's theory about Briony ?? "content

Robbie's theory about Briony

  • We do see characters briefly play detective. Robbie theorises about Briony’s false accusation against him and traces the cause back to an incident eight years’ previous in which Briony deliberately falls into a pool and forces Robbie to jump in and save her from drowning.
  • Briony then tells Robbie that she loves him, something Robbie puts down to a “schoolgirlish passion” which Briony must have “hidden” and “nurtured” (p233) for three years which in turn led to her feeling “betrayed” by Robbie “favouring her sister” (p233).
Illustrative background for Cecilia's role as detectiveIllustrative background for Cecilia's role as detective ?? "content

Cecilia's role as detective

  • Cecilia also plays the role of detective, convinced that it had been Danny Hardman who had sexually assaulted Lola.

Briony and the Reader as Detectives in Atonement

The closest to a detective figure in the novel is Briony. It is she who begins to piece together a story when she observes Robbie and Cecilia by the fountain in Chapter 3.

Illustrative background for Briony introduces criminalityIllustrative background for Briony introduces criminality ?? "content

Briony introduces criminality

  • Briony introduces a criminal element to explain what she has witnessed (“What strange power did he have over her? Blackmail? Threats?” p38).
  • Robbie’s obscene note to Cecilia is, for Briony, further evidence of Robbie’s criminality (“With the letter, something elemental, brutal, perhaps even criminal had been introduced…” p113) and, when she comes upon him and Cecilia making love in the library, she interprets this as a sexual assault by a “maniac”.
Illustrative background for Briony's misinterpretationsIllustrative background for Briony's misinterpretations ?? "content

Briony's misinterpretations

  • But due to McEwan’s use of different perspectives in the novel, with events focalised through different characters at different points throughout Part One, readers can see that Briony’s assumption of Robbie’s criminality is based on a series of tragic misinterpretations.
  • We witness each of these events being focalised through the perspective of either Cecilia (Chapter 2) or Robbie (Chapters 8 and 11) and so are well aware that Briony’s perspective is flawed.
Illustrative background for Briony stopping the confessionIllustrative background for Briony stopping the confession ?? "content

Briony stopping the confession

  • Just as Lola is on the point of making some form of “confession” (p166), Briony shuts her down and imposes upon Lola her own version of events: “It was Robbie, wasn’t it?”
Illustrative background for The reader as detectiveIllustrative background for The reader as detective ?? "content

The reader as detective

  • This, in turn, places the reader in the role of detective.
  • McEwan positions us to discount Briony’s interpretation of events and invites us to come to our own understanding of what has happened by the island temple.
  • McEwan (or Briony?) has left us with a number of clues, particularly concerning Paul Marshall’s sexual interest in young girls, although, as is traditional with crime texts, the revelation of the identity of the criminal does not arrive until near the end.

Jump to other topics

1Introduction to Atonement

2Chapter Summaries & Analysis: Part One

3Chapter Summaries & Analysis: Part Two

4Chapter Summaries & Analysis: Part Three

5Chapter Summaries & Analysis: Part Four

5.1Epilogue: London, 1999 - Pages 353-371

6Key Character Profiles

7Key Themes

8Writing Techniques

9Context

10Critical Debates

Go student ad image

Unlock your full potential with GoStudent tutoring

  • Affordable 1:1 tutoring from the comfort of your home

  • Tutors are matched to your specific learning needs

  • 30+ school subjects covered

Book a free trial lesson