Aid vs Trade

'Aid or trade' is a long-standing debate in economics, regarding the best way for a less-developed economy (LDE) to develop. But a combination of the two is not an uncommon model for such countries.

Illustrative background for Types of aidIllustrative background for Types of aid ?? "content

Types of aid

  • Bilateral aid - aid between one government and another.
  • Multilateral aid - aid provided by many governments instead of just one government.
  • Tied / conditional aid - when one country donates money or resources to another (bilateral aid) but with conditions attached.
  • Charitable aid - funded by donations from the public through organisations such as Water Aid.
  • Non-financial aid - donation of items, such as malaria nets.
Illustrative background for TradeIllustrative background for Trade ?? "content

Trade

  • Export-led growth and trade with other countries enable an LDE to be self-sufficient and reinvest the proceeds of such an approach.
  • But many LDEs are restricted by issues such as worsening terms of trade - meaning that their exports are continually falling in value relative to more high-end imports.
  • A lack of skilled labour and capital may also mean that LDEs don't have the resources to focus on a profitable export industry, making this strategy unrealistic.

Limitations of Aid

Here are some of arguments for why the benefit of aid is limited:

Illustrative background for CorruptionIllustrative background for Corruption ?? "content

Corruption

  • Corruption can restrict aid from getting to where it needs to go.
Illustrative background for Conflicts of interestIllustrative background for Conflicts of interest ?? "content

Conflicts of interest

  • Aid can lead to less-economically developed governments focussing on keeping the donors happy rather than their own citizens.
Illustrative background for Aid dependencyIllustrative background for Aid dependency ?? "content

Aid dependency

  • African economist Dambisa Moyo argues that a dependency culture on aid might be created, where no government has an incentive to improve.
Illustrative background for Market distortionsIllustrative background for Market distortions ?? "content

Market distortions

  • Firms will focus their resources on trying to secure aid, rather than putting their resources to the best use.

Support for Aid

Here are some of the positive aspects of different types of aid:

Illustrative background for Savings gapIllustrative background for Savings gap ?? "content

Savings gap

  • Less-developed economies (LDEs) have a savings gap and aid can provide a way of filling that gap.
Illustrative background for Increasing the LRASIllustrative background for Increasing the LRAS ?? "content

Increasing the LRAS

  • Project aid can help with building infrastructure to increase the capital stock, especially energy (e.g. electricity generation, to improve efficiency).
Illustrative background for Benefiting human capitalIllustrative background for Benefiting human capital ?? "content

Benefiting human capital

  • Aid can improve healthcare outcomes.
Illustrative background for Mutual benefitIllustrative background for Mutual benefit ?? "content

Mutual benefit

  • Donor countries benefit because recipient countries grow and then demand exports from the donor country.

Jump to other topics

1Introduction to Markets

2Market Failure

3The UK Macroeconomy

4The UK Economy - Policies

5Business Behaviour

6Market Structures

7A Global Perspective

8Finance & Inequality

9Examples of Global Policy

Go student ad image

Unlock your full potential with GoStudent tutoring

  • Affordable 1:1 tutoring from the comfort of your home

  • Tutors are matched to your specific learning needs

  • 30+ school subjects covered

Book a free trial lesson