5.1.4

Demergers

Test yourself

Reasons for Demergers

A demerger is the reversal of a merger between two firms or the reversal of a takeover. One large firm is broken into two or more smaller firms. This can happen because of:

Illustrative background for Diseconomies of scaleIllustrative background for Diseconomies of scale ?? "content

Diseconomies of scale

  • If the firm is too large and is experiencing diseconomies of scale then a firm may decide that a demerger is better for shareholders.
Illustrative background for AntitrustIllustrative background for Antitrust ?? "content

Antitrust

  • Like how governments block some takeovers, a firm may demerge because of government intervention.
  • If a government views a monopoly market structure as a market failure, then the government may force the firm to be broken up.
  • Standard Oil was split up by the US Supreme Court into multiple smaller oil companies in 1911.
Illustrative background for Failed mergerIllustrative background for Failed merger ?? "content

Failed merger

  • If firms merged hoping to cross-sell extra products to customers and this failed then they may demerge.
  • If firms merged to try to cut costs by sharing some costs, but this failed, then they may demerge.
Illustrative background for Underperforming business unitIllustrative background for Underperforming business unit ?? "content

Underperforming business unit

  • If only one part of the business area is underperforming then it may make sense to demerge that part of the business so that management can focus more on the more successful business areas or units.
  • Equity markets may increase the 'multiple' that investors will pay for a business if it only contains 1 successful business instead of 1 successful business and 3 underperforming businesses. Therefore a demerger could create shareholder value.
  • Philips sold off their Philips Lighting business via an IPO to focus on higher margin businesses.
Illustrative background for Investment or debtIllustrative background for Investment or debt ?? "content

Investment or debt

  • A firm may sell off one of its divisions to pay off business debts or to undertake a major investment programme.
  • Hewlett Packard separated their software and hardware businesses in 2017.

The Impact of Demergers

Demergers can have different impacts on businesses, workers and consumers.

Illustrative background for Impact on businessesIllustrative background for Impact on businesses ?? "content

Impact on businesses

  • A business is likely to have a better focus after a demerger.
  • The total equity value of the business units may rise after a de-merger. If the businesses were unrelated, then a 'conglomerate discount' may vanish.
  • If a business was suffering from diseconomies of scale, then a demerger may increase efficiency and lower average cost. However, if the business was operating at the minimum efficient scale, then a lower output may increase average cost.
  • Selling a loss-making business is difficult. People are more likely to want to buy a successful business. 'Realising a loss' on a past acquisition and accepting it was a bad choice may harm management's power in the business.
Illustrative background for Impact on workersIllustrative background for Impact on workers ?? "content

Impact on workers

  • Some workers may be forced to work for a new legal entity or employer. There may be cultural clashes or a fall in morale.
  • If the demerger happens to fund investment, then some of this investment may be in machinery or automation tools that reduce the need for labour.
  • Operating in a smaller firm may be good for workers. Dunbar's number finds that people can operate in groups of up to 150 whilst maintaining strong social relations with all of the other members of the group.
Illustrative background for Impact on consumersIllustrative background for Impact on consumers ?? "content

Impact on consumers

  • If demerging stops a firm suffering from diseconomies of scale, efficiency could rise, costs could fall and prices could also fall, increasing the level of consumer surplus.
  • But if the firm loses economies of scale, costs could rise and prices could rise. This is likely to reduce consumer surplus and consumer welfare.
  • But having more firms in an industry may increase choice and competition, leading to higher quality products/services and lower prices.

Jump to other topics

1Introduction to Markets

2Market Failure

3The UK Macroeconomy

4The UK Economy - Policies

5Business Behaviour

6Market Structures

7A Global Perspective

8Finance & Inequality

9Examples of Global Policy

Go student ad image

Unlock your full potential with GoStudent tutoring

  • Affordable 1:1 tutoring from the comfort of your home

  • Tutors are matched to your specific learning needs

  • 30+ school subjects covered

Book a free trial lesson