Seneca

Themes - Memory vs Reality

English Literature: AQA GCSE Poetry - Power & Conflict, topic 12.1.5

Memory vs Reality

Rumens draws a contrast between the speaker's positive memories of their former home. The speaker also has negative impressions of the city now.

Positive vs negative images

Positive vs negative images

  • The poem uses contrast in its language.
  • Positive, bright images show the speaker's memories of her home.
  • The images are juxtaposed (placed together for effect) with harsh, negative images of the war-torn home now.
  • The juxtaposition shows the power of the speaker's memories that beat the more negative reality.
Irony

Irony

  • Even though the speaker remembers her city fondly, she seems at odds with the people now controlling the city.
  • There is a certain irony in that “they” see the city as “their free city”.
  • However, the language the speaker uses (e.g. “sick with tyrants”) suggests restriction and oppression.
Repetition and change of tone

Repetition and change of tone

  • Repetition of “they” in the last stanza is significant.
  • The poem takes on a more threatening, menacing tone.
  • The speaker seems to feel distant from those who now control her city.

Test yourself on Themes - Memory vs Reality

  • Rumens draws a contrast between the following in The Emigree.

  • What effect does the poem's contrast of images create for the reader?

  • What effect does the repetition of “they” create in the last stanza?

  • These statements show how the speaker feels about the city's new rulers.

Practise this topic for free