Paper 1: Reading - Answering Question 4
English Language: AQA GCSE, topic 3.1.8
Section A: Creative Reading - Question 4
In Section A of Paper 1, you will be given an extract from a modern piece of fiction. Unless you are very lucky and have already read the text, this extract will be unseen.

Question 4
- Question 4 is worth 20 marks.
- You should spend around four minutes reading and 20 minutes writing.
- Question 4 is an evaluation question.
- You will be asked to focus on a particular section of the source and respond to a statement.
- You are basically being asked to explain if you agree with the statement given, and why you think that.

Tips for answering Question 4
- AQA have said that students are allowed to agree, disagree, or agree/disagree partially with the statement.
- Disagreeing completely with the statement is much harder to do successfully.
- Agreeing or partially agreeing and disagreeing is much easier.
- AQA have also stated that students must give their own opinions in this question.
- The question is asking you what you think.
- So don't be afraid to share your ideas!

Critically evaluate
- You should focus on the statement and make a judgement on how effective the writer has been.
- You should use evaluation phrases and make a clear judgement based on the statement you have been given.
- You should identify key language devices/methods used by the writer.
- You should show that you understand the value and effect of the methods you have picked.
- The methods work really well with your argument.

Use varied information from text
- You should carefully select quotations because they are important to the point you have made.
- Quotations should prove your ideas really well.
- Your point and evidence should work perfectly together.
- You should not choose any quotation at random and try to make a point around it.
- Your quotations should be short, well-chosen, and match your points perfectly.

Form a critical response
- You should explain why the writer’s choice of language or approach is effective.
- The choice should link clearly to the statement.
- You should select a quotation that links perfectly to the question.
- You should explain why the writer chose to use the quotation or idea.
- You must bring all your ideas back to the question and the statement you were given.
- You should explain why the writer chose to use the particular method you highlighted.
- You should explain the effect it creates.

Form a critical response (cont.)
- To get the top marks, your ideas must be original.
- Original ideas come from thinking outside the box and picking up on small details in the text.
- You should analyse and explain the effect of the writer’s linguistic choices in the text.
Test yourself on Paper 1: Reading - Answering Question 4
Features of Question 4 from Section A.
What do you need to do when answering Question 4?
How should you evaluate the text when you are answering Question 4 of the reading section (Section A)?
How can you respond to the statement in Question 4 of Section A?
Which response to a statement is usually easier for a student to write well?