Seneca

Impact of Reforms

History: Edexcel A Level Russia, 1917-1991: from Lenin to Yeltsin, topic 5.1.4

The Impact of Gorbachev's Reforms

Many of Gorbachev's reforms backfired on him.

Internal conflict in the Communist Party

Internal conflict in the Communist Party

  • Reforms divided the Communist Party into the more traditional Communist hardliners, more moderate members and the most radical Communists who supported attempts to reform the system.
Knowledge of Soviet history

Knowledge of Soviet history

  • Public knowledge about Soviet history, such as what the government had done during the Great Terror, shocked the population and led to the even greater unpopularity of the government.
Freedom of speech

Freedom of speech

  • Freer media led to the most important organ of the government, the Communist Party, being undermined.
New positions in government

New positions in government

  • Gorbachev created the position of ‘President’, which had not previously existed in the Soviet Union. He thought this would give him more legitimacy, but the position was not elected.
  • Newly elected politicians had much more authority than him.

Historical Assessment - Gorbachev's Role in USSR's Collapse

Although he didn't mean to, Gorbachev helped enable the fall of the USSR.

Strayer's view

Strayer's view

  • ‘Between 1987 and 1990, Gorbachev engineered something close to a political miracle... But at the same time those victories for political reform bypassed, diminished, divided and demoralised the Communist Party. Here, clearly, is one of the central elements in the collapse of the Soviet Union.’
Brown's view of the Soviet economy

Brown's view of the Soviet economy

  • ‘There is no doubt that the attempt to reform the Soviet economy ended in failure. Part of the reason for that was the tension between reforming an existing system to make it work better and replacing that system by one which had a quite different logic. In the early years of ‘perestroika’ [restructuring] the first aim was being pursued - and with only limited success'.
Brown's view cont.

Brown's view cont.

  • 'By 1990-1, while there was not a consensus, there was at least a broad body of support among specialists for the idea that the command economy had to give way to the market economy. It was clearer to Gorbachev than to Yeltsin that this would mean tens of millions of citizens becoming worse off for some years to come. Freeing prices would improve the supply of goods and services but would also raise those prices to a level the majority could ill afford.’

Test yourself on Impact of Reforms

  • Which of these is a shocking crime carried out by the Soviet Government?

Practise this topic for free