Attempts at Economic Reform
History: Edexcel A Level Russia, 1917-1991: from Lenin to Yeltsin, topic 5.1.2
Economic Reforms Between 1985 and 1990
Alongside long-term factors, Gorbachev’s failed economic reforms accelerated the fall of the USSR in the short term.

Gorbachev's phases of reform
- Gorbachev's reforms came in three phases:
- Rationalisation: Gorbachev tried to make improvements to the existing state-controlled command economy.
- Reform: Gorbachev tried to introduce some free market measures into the existing economic structure. He wanted a hybrid of socialism and capitalism.
- Transformation: Gorbachev abandoned the state-controlled command economy entirely.

Rationalisation 1985-1986
- Uskorenie (acceleration) meant a programme of investment and modernisation.
- It failed because borrowing money from Western governments led to a huge rise in the national debt.
- This led to inflation.
- Investment in energy did not have the desired effect.
- Andropov’s anti-alcohol campaign continued.
- But as the state cut alcohol production, people began buying alcohol illegally.
- Alcohol revenues fell by 67 million roubles, and as such, the burden of the alcohol ban became too great.

Reform 1986-1990
- November 1986: Law on Individual Economic Activity - it became legal to take on side jobs in the ‘second’ economy not controlled by the state.
- June 1987: Law on State Enterprises - power was distributed from central government administration to factory managers. Prices were now set at the local level.
- May 1988: Law on Co-Operatives - it became legal to set up large co-operatives. In practice, these were private corporations.

Transformation
- Market reforms led to economic chaos. They fell through the gap between a socialist planned economy and a true free market alternative.
- Shortages of essential goods became more and more severe.
- Distribution of goods such as grain became ever more tricky.
- GDP fell 4% from 1986-90. This led to a drop in approval ratings among politicians. Many were enriching themselves through buying privatised companies.

500 Day Programme
- Gorbachev and Yeltsin's programme in 1990 was designed to transition the economy rapidly to a market model
- Gorbachev ended up turning away from the programme after criticism from hard-line Communists.
- January 1991: Supreme Soviet introduced private property.
- Further reforms allowed ownership of stocks and shares.
- The reforms continued to fail. Production of oil fell 9%, while steel production fell 12%.
- The government was effectively bankrupt by 1991.
Historical Assessments of Gorbachev and his Reforms
Historians disagree over the role Gorbachev played in bringing down the Soviet Union. It is clear that his economic reforms snowballed out of his control.

Spinner's view of the USSR's economic weakness
- ‘Most symptoms of the crisis [of the Soviet Union] and the ultimate breakdown of the system can, in fact, be attributed to the impact of economic failure. Whereas economic modernisation was the motor of success in the earlier decades of the Soviet Union, the economy became the weakest link of the Soviet system.'

McCauley's view of the USSR's economic weakness
- ‘The collapse was the result of unintended consequences of government policies. The economy played a key role here. In an attempt to stimulate a slowing economy, the leadership adopted policies which fatally weakened the political and ideological pillars which sustained the system. This brought down the whole edifice...The conclusion is that poor leadership provoked political and economic collapse.’

Historical views on the impact of Gorbachev's reforms
- Some have said that the policies failed because they did not fit with the existing institutions and approaches.
- Gorbachev was constantly modifying his approach, so his policies had no time to mature.
- Others have suggested that the system was too weak anyway for Gorbachev’s policies to succeed.

Historical views on Gorbachev's role in the collapse of the USSR
- Some say the economy would have collapsed regardless of Gorbachev’s interventions. His attempts may have simply hastened the process.
- Others argue that Gorbachev’s economic reforms could have worked. The mistake he made was that he attempted both economic and political reform at the same time. In doing so, he allowed citizens to protest when the economy failed. This led to the fall of the regime.

Oliver's view of Gorbachev's leadership
- ‘While the Soviet economic model suffered from inherent flaws, these were not the fundamental cause of collapse...By the early 1980s, woefully bad economic signs forced the Soviet leadership to embrace radical policies. Under Gorbachev’s over-confident leadership, the introduction of a heady mixture of political and economic reforms fatally undermined the Soviet system and ensured its ultimate collapse.’

McCauley's view of Gorbachev's leadership
- 'China and Vietnam have demonstrated that it is possible to move from a command to a market economy without undermining the power of the Communist Party. Hence the reasons for the failure of economic reform are political. Gorbachev removed the ideological and political pillars on which the Soviet Union was built.’