Failures of the Provisional Government
History: Edexcel IGCSE Russia & the Soviet Union, 1905-1924, topic 3.1.2
Military Problems
Continuing the war turned out to be a mistake. Many soldiers were angry that Russia had not surrendered. Kerensky lost the support of officers by reducing their power.

Order Number 1
- On 1 March 1917, ‘Order Number 1’ was issued by the soldiers of the Petrograd garrison. It demanded that all military orders by the Provisional Government needed the approval of the Petrograd Soviet.
- This undermined the Provisional Government during the period of Dual Control.

Discipline in the army
- Discipline in the army was controlled by councils of soldiers and not by officers:
- “The orders of the military commission of the State Duma [i.e. the Provisional Government] shall be executed [carried out] only in such cases as they do not conflict with the orders and resolutions of the Soviet of Workers’ and Soldiers’ Deputies [Petrograd Soviet].”
Social Problems
Kerensky and the Provisional Government had problems keeping the peasants under control.

The government and the old regime
- The fundamental problem for the Provisional Government was that it seemed similar to the members of the 1912 Duma and the tsar's old regime.
- The Provisional Government was not representative like the Soviets, which held elections.
- Although the Provisional Government intended to hold an election, the turmoil of 1917 at home and at the front meant that this was impossible.

The peasantry
- The Provisional Government failed to satisfy the peasants.
- Most peasants just wanted to be left to get on with their own lives.
- Many peasants supported the Socialist Revolutionaries, although usually peasants did not have a clear political agenda or ideology.

The redistribution of land
- Many peasants wanted land. Some suggested that they should seize land from their former masters.
- The government wanted to wait for an election before making sweeping changes.
- But many peasants seized land anyway. When the Bolsheviks were looking for support, they played on the peasants’ thirst for land by promising it to them during the October Revolution.
Economic Problems
Russia was on the verge of economic collapse in 1917. The Provisional Government was unable to solve these issues.

Industry
- Basic materials for industry could not reach Russia because of the war.
- This shortage worsened through 1917, and the army was unable to fight effectively because of a lack of weapons.

Farming
- Peasant farmers were forced to join the military.
- This led to weaker agricultural production.
- This led to price rises because of shortages of food.

Transport
- Russia's railway system was unable to supply the cities effectively.
- The system was full taking troops and supplies to the front line.

Inflation
- The value of the rouble also fell because of the war.
- This contributed to even higher prices for food and other goods.
- In Petrograd, crowds even broke into bakeries to get food.
Test yourself on Failures of the Provisional Government
Which of the following are correct?
Who controlled discipline in the army?
When was Order Number 1 passed?
Which of the following about the provisional government are correct?
Which party did many peasants support?