Seneca

Success & Failures on the Western Front

History: Edexcel IGCSE Origins & Causes of the First World War, topic 3.3.3

Outdated Tactics on the Western Front

Technology was advancing, but military tactics were struggling to catch up.

Early tactics

Early tactics

  • Initially, tactics were decided in central headquarters and then sent out to the front line. But it soon became obvious that this was incredibly slow. A better method of communication was needed.
  • Tactics were still based to a large extent on ‘charges at the enemy position'.
  • New weapons made it difficult to remain in the open and cross land.
  • This led to a lot of casualties in the war.
Trench warfare

Trench warfare

  • Between September and November in 1914, the Entente and Central Powers started digging trenches.
  • The trenches stretched for 400 miles from Switzerland to the English Channel.
  • This was the Western Front.
  • Most of the conflict on the Western Front involved trying to attack the enemy trenches in the face of machine gun fire.
Tanks

Tanks

  • Tanks were introduced in September 1916. They were a good way to counter new weapons.
  • They could cross No Man’s Land and crush machine gun nests. But they were very unreliable.

Trench Warfare - Strong Defence and Poor Offence

Trench warfare led to very strong defences, but poor options for attacks.

Strong military defences

Strong military defences

  • In trench warfare, soldiers essentially sheltered in their trenches, using machine guns and rifles to shoot any advancing soldiers.
  • Barbed wire was laid out in front of trenches and put in No Man’s Land (the area between the two sides’ trenches) to create traps.
  • A soldier going “over the top” would leave their side’s trenches and travel across No Man’s Land towards the enemy.
Weak attacks

Weak attacks

  • During an attack, the enemy would fire machine guns and shells at the soldiers. Many were shot in seconds.
  • Barbed wire protected the trenches. Barbed wire was also used to force the enemy down particular paths into 'kill zones'.
  • These zones were covered by machine guns or artillery.
Increasing stalemate

Increasing stalemate

  • It was very hard to make advances and win territory in this trench warfare.
  • Because it was so hard to gain ground, it became a war of attrition, where each side tried to exhaust (run down) the enemy’s resources.
Inadequate offensive weapons

Inadequate offensive weapons

  • Artillery guns, tanks and aircraft (planes) were not particularly effective at this time.
  • Tanks were useless in some conditions. For example, the mud was so thick at the Battle of Passchendaele that they could not be used.

General Sir Douglas Haig

General Haig was the most significant British commander during the war. He was critical to Allied survival during the war of attrition.

Haig's beliefs

Haig's beliefs

  • Haig believed the war would be won on the Western Front.
Battle of the Somme

Battle of the Somme

  • He ordered the Battle of the Somme to relieve the pressure at the Battle of Verdun.
  • Overall, this helped the Allied effort to survive.
Casualties

Casualties

  • But the severity of casualties at the Somme and Passchendaele brought Haig’s name into disrepute - his authority was questioned.

Test yourself on Success & Failures on the Western Front

  • How far did the trenches on the Western Front stretch?

  • What did the introduction of tanks achieve in WWI?

  • What was the main issue with fighting from trenches?

  • After which battles was Field Marshal Haig criticised?

  • Which of these are true of General Sir Douglas Haig?

Practise this topic for free