Evaluating the Pilgrimage of Grace
History: Edexcel GCSE Henry VIII & his Ministers, topic 3.1.8
Reasons for the Pilgrimage of Grace's Failure
There were several reasons for the failure of the Pilgrimage of Grace:

Trusting Henry VIII
- The main reason for the rebellion’s failure was Aske’s faith in the King to keep his promises.
- Aske didn’t know Henry would break his promises.
- He was educated and intelligent, and Henry gave him no reason to distrust him, even inviting him to court for Christmas. Aske was not naive, just tricked.

Reasons for Henry VIII breaking his promises
- Henry could not be seen to give in to the pilgrim’s demands as it would weaken his reputation.
- It would also be impossible for him to admit the failure of his political and religious reforms.

Dissolution after the Pilgrimage of Grace
- Henry actually sped up the Dissolution after the Pilgrimage as he saw monasteries as a centre for the opposition.

Council of the North
- Henry increased the power of the Council of the North to deal with any further unrest.
Significance of the Pilgrimage of Grace
Despite the eventual defeat of the Pilgrimage of Grace, it was still significant.

The scale of rebellion
- The Pilgrimage of Grace was the largest rebellion any Tudor monarch faced and showed just how unpopular his religious policies were.

Strength of Henry VIII's army
- The pilgrims probably would have won if they had faced Henry’s army in battle as they were well-armed, disciplined and determined.
- There were 40,000 of them against only a few thousand under Norfolk.

Negotiating with Henry VIII
- The pilgrims forced Henry to make compromises.
- He had to negotiate with them and granted a pardon when he personally wanted to punish them and had to promise to stop the dissolution and hold a northern parliament.