Seneca

Capital Punishment

History: Edexcel GCSE Crime & Punishment, topic 4.2.3

The Abolition of the Death Penalty in Modern Britain

The abolition of the death penalty reflects the changing attitudes of the period.

The scale of capital punishment

The scale of capital punishment

  • Public execution ended in 1868 but the death penalty continued to be used in prisons until 1965.
  • In reality, however, there were a low number of executions each year.
  • An average of 14 people a year were executed for murder.
Impact of WW2

Impact of WW2

  • Following the Second World War attitudes towards capital punishment began to change.
  • As a result of the Holocaust, there was an increasing feeling that the death penalty was un-Christian and barbaric.
  • The 1948 Declaration of Human Rights issued by the United Nations stated that ‘everyone has a right to life’.
The death penalty in 1957

The death penalty in 1957

  • In 1957 the British government abolished the use of the death penalty for all cases except the murder of a police officer, murder by shooting or explosion, murder whilst resisting arrest, murder whilst carrying out theft and murder of more than one person.
  • High profile cases where there was a miscarriage of justice helped change attitudes towards the use of capital punishment.
The death penalty from 1965-98

The death penalty from 1965-98

  • Capital punishment was abolished in 1965 for all crimes except treason in times of war and piracy.
  • This was initially for a 5-year trial but the government abolished its use permanently in 1969.
  • Capital punishment could still legally be used in cases of treason and piracy, however, this was also abolished in 1998, making Britain fully abolitionist.
The last execution

The last execution

  • The last woman to be hanged was Ruth Ellis in 1955 for the murder of her lover David Blakely in a crime of passion.

Evaluating Capital Punishment

The issue of capital punishment provokes debate and controversy. There are arguments for and against it.

Arguments for capital punishment

Arguments for capital punishment

  • It was the greatest deterrent against crime possible.
  • Criminals would be more likely to carry weapons if there was no danger of them being hanged for murder.
  • Life imprisonment costs a lot and in many ways is more cruel to an offender.
  • Those who have completed a sentence for murder are likely to kill again.
  • Execution proved how serious the crime of murder is and furthermore it avenged the death of the victim.
Arguments against capital punishment

Arguments against capital punishment

  • Sometimes mistakes are made and the wrong person is executed.
  • Examples of this include:
    • The case of Timothy Evans who was hanged for murder in 1950 and posthumously pardoned in 1966.
  • The case of Derek Bentley who was executed for murder in 1953.
  • Many murders are spur of the moment things.
  • This means that capital punishment is not really a deterrent in these cases.
  • Execution is not Christian and goes against the idea of the sanctity of life.

Test yourself on Capital Punishment

  • When did public executions end in Britain?

  • When was the death penalty abolished in Britain for all crimes except treason in times of war and piracy?

  • Which of the following mean capital punishment would not be an effective deterrent?

  • When was Derek Bentley executed?

Practise this topic for free