Source: https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-8-evaluating-the-pilgrimage-of-grace

[Revision notes](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes.md) › [GCSE](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse.md) › [History](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history.md) › [Edexcel](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel.md) › [History: Edexcel GCSE Henry VIII & his Ministers](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers.md) › Evaluating the Pilgrimage of Grace

# Evaluating the Pilgrimage of Grace

History: Edexcel GCSE Henry VIII & his Ministers, topic 3.1.8

## Reasons for the Pilgrimage of Grace's Failure

There were several reasons for the failure of the Pilgrimage of Grace:

### Trusting Henry VIII

![Trusting Henry VIII](https://image-v2.cdn.app.senecalearning.com/2018-07/87ffde21-97fd-4551-ba97-b47ed350442d/Oath-Swearing-Bible-Book-Hand-.jpg)

- The main reason for the rebellion’s failure was Aske’s faith in the King to keep his promises.
- Aske didn’t know Henry would break his promises.
- He was educated and intelligent, and Henry gave him no reason to distrust him, even inviting him to court for Christmas. Aske was not naive, just tricked.

### Reasons for Henry VIII breaking his promises

![Reasons for Henry VIII breaking his promises](https://image-v2.cdn.app.senecalearning.com/2018-09/ef903c04-b83d-4b88-a529-9b7ac11d0f2e/fail-failure-.jpg)

- Henry could not be seen to give in to the pilgrim’s demands as it would weaken his reputation.
- It would also be impossible for him to admit the failure of his political and religious reforms.

### Dissolution after the Pilgrimage of Grace

![Dissolution after the Pilgrimage of Grace](https://image-v2.cdn.app.senecalearning.com/2018-09/368a76ad-99e2-41ef-be13-48b69e50fe7a/rush-hurry-deadline-time-clock-.jpg)

- Henry actually sped up the Dissolution after the Pilgrimage as he saw monasteries as a centre for the opposition.

### Council of the North

![Council of the North](https://image-v2.cdn.app.senecalearning.com/2018-12/b4fb390f-13d0-4ab5-8100-2c1b90ea0ab1/angel-of-the-north-england-.jpg)

- Henry increased the power of the Council of the North to deal with any further unrest.

## Significance of the Pilgrimage of Grace

Despite the eventual defeat of the Pilgrimage of Grace, it was still significant.

### The scale of rebellion

![The scale of rebellion](https://image-v2.cdn.app.senecalearning.com/2018-07/5c47679b-6047-4351-aec1-40c37e50bd13/Military.Graveyard.jpg)

- The Pilgrimage of Grace was the largest rebellion any Tudor monarch faced and showed just how unpopular his religious policies were.

### Strength of Henry VIII's army

![Strength of Henry VIII's army](https://image-v2.cdn.app.senecalearning.com/2018-04/0b0ff512-1136-4d04-bd83-9e7d357fbecf/shutterstock_716498566.jpg)

- The pilgrims probably would have won if they had faced Henry’s army in battle as they were well-armed, disciplined and determined.
- There were 40,000 of them against only a few thousand under Norfolk.

### Negotiating with Henry VIII

![Negotiating with Henry VIII](https://image-v2.cdn.app.senecalearning.com/2018-10/c4349ffb-742b-43b4-b0ff-6bc291477fd7/henry-thomas-.jpg)

- The pilgrims forced Henry to make compromises.
- He had to negotiate with them and granted a pardon when he personally wanted to punish them and had to promise to stop the dissolution and hold a northern parliament.

## Test yourself on Evaluating the Pilgrimage of Grace

[Practise this topic for free](https://app.senecalearning.com/classroom/course/6d52b686-09fc-4d64-84cc-7a33dcf942cc/section/1298528e-482f-4163-b483-eb2f48edde8a/session)

- Previous topic: [3.1.7 The Pilgrimage of Grace](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-7-the-pilgrimage-of-grace.md)
- Next topic: [3.1.9 End of Topic Test - The Reformation](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-9-end-of-topic-test-the-reformation.md)

## History: Edexcel GCSE Henry VIII & his Ministers contents

### 1 Henry VIII & Wolsey, 1509-1529
- 1.1 Henry VIII & Wolsey, 1509-1529
  - [1.1.1 Henry VIII, Renaissance Prince](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/1-1-1-henry-viii-renaissance-prince.md)
  - [1.1.2 The Rise of Wolsey](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/1-1-2-the-rise-of-wolsey.md)
  - [1.1.3 Wolsey's Domestic Reforms](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/1-1-3-wolseys-domestic-reforms.md)
  - [1.1.4 Wolsey's Foreign Policy](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/1-1-4-wolseys-foreign-policy.md)
  - [1.1.5 Evaluating Wolsey's Foreign Policy](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/1-1-5-evaluating-wolseys-foreign-policy.md)
  - [1.1.6 The Succession & Annulment](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/1-1-6-the-succession-and-annulment.md)
  - [1.1.7 Fall of Wolsey](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/1-1-7-fall-of-wolsey.md)
  - [1.1.8 End of Topic Test - Henry VIII & Wolsey](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/1-1-8-end-of-topic-test-henry-viii-and-wolsey.md)
  - [1.1.9 End of Topic Test - Henry VIII & Wolsey 2](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/1-1-9-end-of-topic-test-henry-viii-and-wolsey-2.md)

### 2 Henry VIII & Cromwell, 1529-1540
- 2.1 Henry VIII & Cromwell, 1529-1540
  - [2.1.1 The Rise of Cromwell](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/2-1-1-the-rise-of-cromwell.md)
  - [2.1.2 The King's Annulment](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/2-1-2-the-kings-annulment.md)
  - [2.1.3 Cromwell & the King's Marriages](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/2-1-3-cromwell-and-the-kings-marriages.md)
  - [2.1.4 Cromwell & Government](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/2-1-4-cromwell-and-government.md)
  - [2.1.5 Cromwell & Parliament](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/2-1-5-cromwell-and-parliament.md)
  - [2.1.6 Fall of Cromwell](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/2-1-6-fall-of-cromwell.md)
  - [2.1.7 End of Topic Test - Henry VIII & Cromewell](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/2-1-7-end-of-topic-test-henry-viii-and-cromewell.md)
  - [2.1.8 End of Topic Test - Henry VIII & Cromwell 2](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/2-1-8-end-of-topic-test-henry-viii-and-cromwell-2.md)

### 3 The Reformation & its Impact, 1529-1540
- 3.1 The Reformation & its Impact, 1529-1540
  - [3.1.1 The Break with Rome](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-1-the-break-with-rome.md)
  - [3.1.2 Opposition to the Reformation](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-2-opposition-to-the-reformation.md)
  - [3.1.3 Impact of the Reformation](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-3-impact-of-the-reformation.md)
  - [3.1.4 Role of Religious Houses](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-4-role-of-religious-houses.md)
  - [3.1.5 Dissolution of the Monasteries](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-5-dissolution-of-the-monasteries.md)
  - [3.1.6 Impact of Dissolution](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-6-impact-of-dissolution.md)
  - [3.1.7 The Pilgrimage of Grace](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-7-the-pilgrimage-of-grace.md)
  - [3.1.8 Evaluating the Pilgrimage of Grace](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-8-evaluating-the-pilgrimage-of-grace.md)
  - [3.1.9 End of Topic Test - The Reformation](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-9-end-of-topic-test-the-reformation.md)
  - [3.1.10 End of Topic Test - The Reformation 2](https://senecalearning.com/en-gb/revision-notes/gcse/history/edexcel/henry-viii-and-his-ministers/3-1-10-end-of-topic-test-the-reformation-2.md)
